Marketing agency vs doing it yourself vs a done-for-you monthly plan
DIY is cheapest in cash and most expensive in time; an agency suits ads and big campaigns; a done-for-you plan suits the routine upkeep most local shops actually need.
For an owner-run shop, "marketing" usually means five routine jobs, not a campaign: a website that is current, a Google Business Profile that is complete, a reply to every review, a steady trickle of social posts, and someone checking whether you show up when people search. The question is who does those jobs. There are three honest answers.
The comparison at a glance
| Do it yourself | Agency or freelancer | Done-for-you monthly plan | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash cost | Lowest: builder plan and tools | Highest: retainer or project fees | Fixed monthly price |
| Your time | Highest: every task is yours | Meetings, approvals, briefs | Low: send facts and photos by email |
| Best at | Owners who like it | Paid ads, branding, big launches | Routine upkeep that must happen every week |
| Main risk | It slips when the shop is busy | Paying for strategy you do not need | Less custom than a bespoke agency |
Doing it yourself
Everything a local shop needs can be done for free or nearly free by the owner. Google's Business Profile is free, replying to reviews is free, and posting on Facebook and Instagram is free. Website builders cost roughly $20 to $40 a month; see our breakdown of what a small business website costs.
The cost is time and consistency. Reviews need replies within the week. Holiday hours need setting before the holiday. Posts need a calendar. The common failure is that it stops when the shop gets busy, which is exactly when customers are searching.
DIY wins when you enjoy it, you have a regular slot for it every week, or someone in the family does it well.
Hiring an agency or freelancer
A good agency brings strategy, design and paid advertising skill. If you want to run Google Ads, launch a new location with a campaign, or rebrand, an agency or an experienced freelancer is the right tool.
For routine upkeep, the fit is weaker. Agency work is priced by hours, so small recurring jobs (one review reply, one holiday notice) are expensive per task, and many agencies have minimum retainers. Before you sign, ask:
- What exactly is delivered each month, as a list?
- Who owns the website, domain, ad account and Google profile? (Answer should be: you.)
- Is there a minimum term, and what happens to your site if you leave?
- Will they ever post reviews, buy followers or offer customers incentives for reviews? (Answer should be: never. Google prohibits incentives for reviews, see its content policy.)
An agency wins when you need ads, a brand, or a launch, and have the budget for it.
A done-for-you monthly plan
A done-for-you plan does the routine jobs on a schedule for a fixed price. You send facts ("closed Monday", "new price for a beard trim") by email or text and the plan's team makes the change. Storefront Monthly is this kind of service, and it is made with AI software and checked by King AI before anything goes out; that is how the price stays low.
| Plan | Price | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| Starter | $99/mo | Website, Google profile upkeep with 4 posts a month, every new review answered |
| Growth | $249/mo | Starter plus menu, price or booking page with QR code, 30 social posts, monthly local and AI search report |
| Pro | $499/mo | Growth plus Spanish versions, a monthly local blog post, seasonal flyer and newsletter |
What it does not do: paid ads, bought leads, and anything you have not approved or published yourself. No contract; the first month is refundable on request within 14 days. Before you pay, you can see a free month-one preview built from your public listing, like our sample month for a Bloomington barbershop.
A done-for-you plan wins when the jobs are routine, they keep slipping, and your time is worth more in the shop.
A simple way to choose
- If you want to run ads or rebrand: talk to an agency.
- If you have a reliable weekly hour and like the work: do it yourself, with our Google Business Profile checklist.
- If the routine keeps slipping: hand the routine to a monthly plan and keep your weekly hour for the customers in front of you.
Questions
Can I mix these?
Yes. Many shops run a done-for-you plan for the routine work and hire a freelancer for a one-off project such as a logo or an ad campaign.
Is AI-made marketing any good?
It depends on the checks. Our rule is that every reply and post uses only facts you or your public listing provide, and King AI checks every piece before anything goes out.